The point
The Yes Bank case over ₹8,415 crore of AT1 bonds shows that a bond's terms decide what its yield never shows. Those are who can write the bond off, whether the coupon is owed, and how the principal returns if a court reverses the write-off. As of 16 November 2026 all three are still being argued, after Yes Bank filed a review petition in the Supreme Court.
What did the Yes Bank AT1 case leave unsettled?
An Additional Tier 1 (AT1) bond is a perpetual bank bond, one with no maturity date, that counts as regulatory capital. The coupon, which is the interest the bond pays, is higher than on ordinary bank debt because the principal can be written off when the bank is in trouble.
Yes Bank wrote down two such series in March 2020 during its reconstruction. One was ₹3,000 crore at a 9.5 percent coupon, issued in December 2016. The other was ₹5,415 crore at 9 percent, issued in October 2017. The Bombay High Court quashed the write-down in January 2023. On 15 October 2026 the Supreme Court dismissed the appeals of Yes Bank, the Reserve Bank of India and the Centre. Business Today set out that sequence on 14 November 2026.
Business Standard reported on 13 November 2026 that Yes Bank filed a review petition under Article 137 of the Constitution, which asks the court to reconsider its own judgment. The reports read for this piece give no hearing date.
The judgment undid the write-down but left open how the bonds come back and what is owed on them in the meantime. Outlook Business, citing the Economic Times, noted that the court directed no immediate cash repayment of ₹8,415 crore and put no number on any liability arising from past coupons.
Sources, all read 16 November 2026. Business Standard: https://www.business-standard.com/companies/news/yes-bank-seeks-sc-review-of-ruling-on-8-415-crore-at-1-bond-write-down-126111301764_1.html. Business Today: https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/corporate/story/yes-bank-moves-supreme-court-for-review-of-rs8415-crore-at1-bond-ruling-567458-2026-11-14. Outlook Business: https://www.outlookbusiness.com/corporate/yes-bank-to-move-to-supreme-court-over-8415-cr-at1-bonds.
How do you read an AT1 bond's terms before the yield?
Every answer below sits in the bond's information memorandum, the offer document that sets out its terms. The Yes Bank case turned on exactly these documents, and the steps run in the order a holder's money is exposed.
Step 1: find who can pull the loss trigger
Find the clause that lets the principal be written off, and then find who decides that it has been met and under which scheme or law. In the Yes Bank case the trustee challenged the March 2020 write-down in May 2020. The High Court ruled in January 2023 and the Supreme Court in October 2026, so the question of authority took more than six years. A coupon of 9.5 percent tells you a trigger exists, and only the clause tells you who holds it.
Step 2: check whether the coupon is discretionary
Business Standard reports that the Supreme Court held annual coupons unaffected by the outcome of the appeals, payable in accordance with the information memorandums. Business Today reports that on 30 October 2026 Yes Bank replied to the bondholders' trustee that coupon payments are governed by those memorandums, including applicable discretion. Where a memorandum lets the issuer skip a coupon, the stated rate is a ceiling. Read the clause that says when a coupon can be skipped, and whether a skipped coupon is ever made up.
Step 3: ask how the principal returns if a write-off is reversed
A court can set a write-down aside, but a bond still has to be put back on the register. Business Standard reports that the trustee, Axis Trustee Services, sought restoration of the instruments in the depository and exchange records. Business Today adds that on 28 October the trustee asked Yes Bank to reinstate them within three days. Finimize, citing Reuters, reports that on 6 November the trustee filed a contempt petition, saying the bank had not given a concrete roadmap for restoring the bonds. The bank's position on that petition is not in the reports read for this piece. Reversing a write-off is a process with steps of its own, so check whether the memorandum describes it at all.
Step 4: find what the issuer's own capital does with the bond
Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) is the issuer's highest-quality capital, mainly shareholders' equity. Yes Bank estimated that reinstating the full ₹8,415 crore would lower its CET1 ratio by about 250 basis points. A basis point is one hundredth of a percentage point, so 250 of them is 2.5 percentage points. The estimate is pro forma on the June 2026 position, and the bank has booked no such loss. Its Tier 1 ratio would stay at 14 percent on the same basis, because the revived bonds count as Additional Tier 1 capital again. The bond's treatment changes the issuer's own capital, which is why the issuer has a stake in how it is treated.
Step 5: size the position for a full write-off
Decide the position as if the trigger will be pulled and the coupon skipped, then ask whether you would hold it.
Sources for Steps 2 to 4: Business Standard, Business Today and Outlook Business, as linked above. Finimize, read 16 November 2026: https://finimize.com/content/yes-banks-at-1-bond-fight-heads-back-to-indias-top-court.
What does the worked example look like at portfolio scale?
Take a ₹1 crore portfolio and a 9.5 percent AT1 coupon like the larger Yes Bank series. These figures are an illustration of the arithmetic and not a forecast for any bond.
A position of 3 percent is ₹3 lakh. At a 9.5 percent coupon that pays ₹28,500 a year (₹3,00,000 × 0.095). If the principal is written off, the loss is ₹3 lakh, which is 3 percent of the portfolio and about 10.5 years of coupons (₹3,00,000 ÷ ₹28,500).
A position of 25 percent is ₹25 lakh. The coupon is ₹2,37,500 a year (₹25,00,000 × 0.095). The same write-off takes ₹25 lakh, a quarter of the portfolio, and a skipped coupon removes ₹2,37,500 in one year. The first position survives the clause going wrong, and the second makes it the main event of the year.
Now a ₹5 lakh lump sum in the 9 percent series. The coupon is ₹45,000 a year (₹5,00,000 × 0.09). Suppose the memorandum allows the coupon to be skipped for three years. The income across those years is ₹0 against ₹1,35,000 if every coupon were paid. The ₹5 lakh stays exposed to the loss trigger the whole time.
What does this have to do with crypto?
The reader's question is the same one in both markets: what exactly is the claim, and who can change its terms? An AT1 holder answers it from an information memorandum. A basket holder answers it from the rules the basket publishes.
Qatobit publishes the methodology of each QSI index. It is the rule that decides what the basket holds and how it rebalances each month, so the terms are readable before the money goes in. Custody is institutional, and a live Proof of Reserves is available at any time. Before you invest in QSI Growth, read the QSI Growth methodology the way Step 1 reads a trigger clause.
For the platform side of the same habit, how to read a proof-of-reserves attestation covers what a reserves report shows and what it leaves out. For the ruling itself and the five checks that came out of it, see what the Yes Bank ruling changes for AT1 holders. This piece picks up where that one stops: the terms the ruling left open.
Frequently asked questions
What is an AT1 bond?
An Additional Tier 1 bond is a perpetual bank bond that counts as regulatory capital and can be written off when specified triggers are met. It pays a higher coupon than ordinary bank debt because of that clause.
What is Yes Bank's review petition about?
Yes Bank filed a review petition under Article 137 of the Constitution, reported on 13 November 2026, asking the Supreme Court to reconsider its 15 October 2026 judgment. That judgment upheld the quashing of the ₹8,415 crore AT1 write-down. The reports read for this piece give no hearing date.
Are AT1 coupons guaranteed?
No. Business Standard reports that the Supreme Court held the Yes Bank coupons payable in accordance with the information memorandums. Business Today reports that the bank cites applicable discretion in those documents. A coupon is owed only as far as its memorandum says it is.
Did the ruling mean Yes Bank had to repay ₹8,415 crore in cash?
No. Outlook Business, citing the Economic Times, reports that the court directed no immediate cash repayment and put no number on any liability from past coupons. Yes Bank estimated a pro forma CET1 impact of about 250 basis points, which is a capital estimate and not a payment.
How much of a portfolio should sit in one AT1 bond?
Size it as a loss you could absorb. A ₹3 lakh position in a ₹1 crore portfolio is 3 percent, and a full write-off costs ₹3 lakh, about 10.5 years of coupons at 9.5 percent.
Crypto investments are subject to market risk. Not financial advice.
“A better allocation begins with a better explanation.”
Qatobit principle
Published construction. Fixed cadence. Versioned control.



